- Basedment
- Posts
- Is It Trump's Time To Win The Nobel Peace prize?
Is It Trump's Time To Win The Nobel Peace prize?
Your daily dose of geopolitical updates and strategic analysis. Unbiased, but not unbased.
THE BRIEFING
Here’s what’s happening in geopolitics today.
A mix of diplomacy, security, and civil unrest headlines dominated the past 24 hours.
The UK is tightening protest laws following a deadly synagogue attack, while Israel and Hamas prepare to discuss Trump’s proposed Gaza peace plan. In Europe, Germany is rethinking how much control the state should have over its defence industry, and Spain saw violent clashes at a pro-Palestinian march.
In today’s deep dive, we take a look at Donald Trump’s Nobel Peace Prize bid, and why, despite his high-profile diplomacy, he may be unlikely to bring home the world’s most prestigious peace award.
THE LAST 24 HOURS IN GEOPOLITICS
1. UK to introduce limits on protests after Synagogue attack
In response to a deadly attack on a synagogue in Manchester, the UK government is introducing new powers for police to restrict “repeat protests” in the same area to mitigate community tensions. Interior Minister Shabana Mahmood said senior officers will be able to consider the cumulative impact of past demonstrations when deciding whether to impose conditions, move or even ban future protests. Critics have raised concerns that the measures may interfere with civil liberties, but the government frames them as necessary to balance the right to protest with public safety and community well-being.
read more
2. Israel, Hamas to discuss Trump peace plan on Monday
Israel and Hamas are scheduled to begin discussions on Donald Trump’s 20-point Gaza peace plan on Monday, mediated indirectly through regional partners. Israel has publicly supported the framework, while Hamas remains noncommittal, having accepted parts but deferred key issues like disarmament and governance. The upcoming talks will test whether both sides are serious about compromise, or simply buying time for larger strategic manoeuvres.
read more
3. UK PM Starmer to visit India on 8-9 October
UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer is set to make his first official visit to India on October 8–9, invited by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, according to India’s Foreign Ministry. The visit comes on the heels of the UK-India free trade agreement signed in July and aims to deepen cooperation in areas like trade, technology, defence and innovation. Starmer is expected to attend India’s Global Fintech Fest in Mumbai and cement momentum behind the emerging “Vision 2035” strategic partnership.
read more
4. German Minister wants more State ownership in defence firms
German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius has called for stronger state participation in the defence sector, arguing that government involvement is essential to preserve jobs and technical know-how within Germany. His comments come amid broader efforts to speed up procurement, support domestic arms manufacturers, and boost resilience in critical defence supply chains. The proposals reflect growing concern that without state support, Germany may lose out in key technology areas and lag behind in keeping its defence industry competitive.
read more
5. Eight arrested, 20 police hurt in clashes at Spanish Palestine march
Around 70,000 people took to the streets in Barcelona in a pro-Palestinian march triggered by the detention of flotilla activists, and though largely peaceful, clashes broke out, resulting in eight arrests and 20 injured police officers, local authorities said. Some protesters vandalised shops they claimed had Israel ties, fuelling tension between demonstrators and law enforcement. The unrest comes amid widespread anger in Spain and elsewhere over Israel’s interception of the Global Sumud aid flotilla.
read more
DAILY DEEP DIVE
Donald Trump and the 2025 Nobel Peace Prize Debate
The Nobel Peace Prize is awarded each year to the person or organisation deemed to have “done the most or the best work for fraternity between nations.” As Alfred Nobel’s will specifies, laureates are chosen by a five-member committee appointed by the Norwegian parliament. Qualified nominators may propose candidates by January 31 each year. After a closed-door review of hundreds of nominations, the committee shortlists contenders, consults expert advisers, and selects a winner by October, with the award ceremony held in Oslo in December. Committee deliberations are secret for 50 years, so announced names usually follow traditional criteria emphasising broad, lasting contributions to peace.
Arguments in Favour of Trump’s Candidacy
Supporters argue that President Trump’s diplomacy deserves Nobel recognition. In July 2025, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu publicly handed Trump a letter nominating him, praising his role in seeking a “better future” for Palestinians. Back in 2020, Trump brokered the Abraham Accords which Netanyahu hailed as evidence of Trump’s “vision and bold leadership” for Middle East peace. Domestically, Trump’s allies have been vocal. At a June Cabinet meeting, his Middle East envoy Steve Witkoff declared the president “the single finest candidate” ever discussed for the Nobel Prize. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said “it is well past time” Trump received the award, and several Republican lawmakers have also submitted formal nominations, arguing he has done “more for world peace than any modern leader.”
In Eastern Europe, Ukraine’s foreign affairs chairman Oleksandr Merezhko, from President Zelensky’s party, nominated Trump for 2025, citing his first-term role in mediating Israel–Arab agreements and providing Ukraine with Javelin missiles early in the Russian invasion. Some supporters also point to Trump’s recent statements that he can negotiate end-of-war deals suggesting these initiatives merit consideration. In short, proponents emphasise his headline-grabbing peace efforts and argue that his pragmatic deal-making approach has already reshaped global diplomacy.
Arguments Against Trump’s Candidacy
Critics argue that Trump’s record conflicts with Nobel ideals of international cooperation. The Nobel statutes call for promoting “fellowship among nations,” but many observers note Trump has pursued unilateral, “America First” policies. For example, he withdrew the U.S. from the World Health Organisation and the Paris climate agreement, and imposed tariffs on allies, actions seen as running counter to the spirit of global collaboration. Peace researchers in Norway have described Trump as having “no chance” of winning, citing his support for Israel’s military campaign in Gaza and outreach to leaders like Vladimir Putin.
Nobel Committee members are also known to discourage overt campaigning. The committee’s deputy chair has warned that public lobbying and political pressure “tend to backfire,” since the committee values independence from influence. Trump’s own frequent public appeals are unlikely to sway the panel and may even reinforce skepticism. Some commentators have described the push from within his administration as overly performative, noting that past laureates like Barack Obama or Henry Kissinger were recognized for actions that tangibly reduced conflict or advanced diplomacy. By contrast, Trump’s tenure is viewed by critics as having heightened divisions and weakened multilateral engagement.
Ultimately, while Trump’s supporters frame his candidacy as overdue recognition for his foreign policy initiatives, the Nobel Committee’s decision will hinge on its traditional criteria -measurable progress toward peace, international cooperation, and enduring impact. For now, the growing debate underscores how the Nobel Peace Prize remains not just an award, but a reflection of how the world defines and rewards the pursuit of peace.
Sources:
Sources available upon request, not shown to maintain visual integrity of page.
TWEET OF THE DAY
Hegseth has absolutely no-chill 😂
TODAY IN HISTORY
(October 5, 1813): Battle of the Thames
On this day in 1813, during the War of 1812, a British army with some 1,000 Indian allies under the famed leader Tecumseh was defeated by U.S. troops in the Battle of the Thames in what is now Ontario, Canada.
