US Oil Tanker Seizure And Russia's Deterrence Problem

THE BRIEFING 

Here’s what’s happening in geopolitics today.

Global diplomacy and power politics are moving fast today, from turmoil inside Yemen’s anti-Houthi camp to fresh friction between Washington and its allies over Greenland and multilateral institutions.

The U.S. is also reshaping its relationships closer to home and abroad, by inviting Colombia’s president to Washington, seizing a Russian-flagged tanker tied to Venezuela, and formally pulling back from dozens of international bodies.

Later in the newsletter, we zoom in on the latest U.S. SOF seizure of the Bella-1 and how this represents a wider deterrence problem for Russia.

A WORD FROM OUR SPONSOR  

You could be wasting hundreds on car insurance

If your auto insurance rate went up in the last 12 months, check this before paying your next bill! All you have to do is enter your zip code and car info to find better insurance options. You could save up to $600 per year!

See How Much You Can Save

THE LAST 24 HOURS IN GEOPOLITICS 

1. Saudi-led coalition says Yemen separatist leader boarded vessel to Somaliland
The Saudi-led coalition in Yemen said on Thursday that Aidarous al-Zubaidi, leader of the UAE-backed Southern Transitional Council (STC), boarded a vessel bound for Somaliland and later flew onward to Mogadishu, Somalia, although the statement did not confirm whether he remained on the aircraft during its subsequent flight to a military airport in Abu Dhabi. The report follows recent turmoil after Zubaidi failed to attend scheduled peace talks in Riyadh, with the coalition accusing him of mobilising armed forces and moving to an unidentified location, deepening rifts within the anti-Houthi coalition.
read more 

2. Rubio to meet Denmark next week as Trump escalates Greenland rhetoric
Marco Rubio said he will meet with Danish officials next week to discuss Washington’s interest in Greenland, as diplomatic tensions have risen following renewed comments by Trump about acquiring the strategically important Arctic territory. Rubio emphasised that the U.S. prefers a diplomatic solution and reiterated that every president retains the option to address national security threats through military means, but he did not rule out that possibility when asked, underscoring broader concerns about alliance dynamics. The meeting comes as Denmark and Greenland have both rejected the idea of selling or ceding control of the island.
read more

3. Trump invites Colombian President to White House after threatening his country
Trump invited Colombian President Gustavo Petro to the White House next week, marking a dramatic shift in tone following recent public disputes and threats, including Trump’s comments about possible U.S. intervention in Colombia. The invitation came after the two leaders spoke by phone to discuss disagreements over drug trafficking and other issues, with Trump saying he “appreciated his call and tone” and looked forward to meeting Petro in Washington.
read more

4. US seizes Russian-flagged oil tanker linked to Venezuela
The United States has seized a Russian-flagged oil tanker with links to Venezuelan sanctions evasion after a weeks-long pursuit across the North Atlantic, U.S. European Command said, marking what officials described as enforcement of sanctions tied to Venezuela’s oil exports. The vessel, originally known as the Bella 1 and later renamed Marinera after changing its flag and identity while attempting to evade a U.S. maritime blockade, was intercepted under a U.S. federal court warrant for sanctions violations and is seen by Washington as part of a “shadow fleet” transporting oil for Venezuela, Russia and Iran. Moscow condemned the action as a violation of international law, even as U.S. authorities maintain the seizure was lawful.
read more

5. Trump to withdraw US from dozens of UN, international organisations
Trump signed a presidential memorandum ordering the United States to withdraw from 66 international organisations and treaties, including 31 United Nations entities and 35 non-UN bodies, after a White House review concluded they no longer serve American national interests. The list of organisations from which the U.S. will exit includes key climate and multilateral cooperation frameworks and involves ending both participation and funding for these bodies. The administration argues the move will protect U.S. sovereignty and redirect taxpayer dollars to American priorities.
read more

DAILY DEEP DIVE

BELLA-1 AS A CASE STUDY FOR FAILED RUSSIAN DETERRENCE

So, as we have all seen, a weeks-long geopolitical drama has come to an end in the last 24 hours. Bella-1 was boarded by U.S. special operations forces, flown in by the 160th — the same unit used in the capture and extraction of Maduro and his wife just days earlier. The big question everyone is asking is: what was on that tanker? It was clearly not filled with oil, otherwise the ship would have been sitting much lower in the water. Regardless, it was publicly stated that the vessel was not carrying any major cargo.

Could it have been military hardware? Some speculated a tactical nuclear device to provide deterrence. Others suggested it wasn’t an object at all, but a person. There are a great many possibilities, and no shortage of James Bond or Tom Clancy-grade theories. If we are talking about hardware, possibilities range from air-defence systems,  perhaps an S-400 with its full operating kit, to drones, or even Russian intelligence personnel. Who knows.

“NOTHING EVER HAPPENS”
But the answer is probably far more boring than many would like to imagine. Going back to the “nothing ever happens” meme, it could really be as simple as this: the U.S. announced a naval blockade on Venezuela and said it would stop sanctioned tankers. Three weeks ago, Bella-1 was heading there, refused boarding, and the U.S. pursued it to demonstrate that the blockade is real.

To me, however, this story represents a much larger geopolitical talking point — namely, Russia’s growing difficulty in projecting power and enforcing deterrence. Countries aligned with the anti-Western bloc are extremely limited in how they navigate both soft and hard power. There are many reasons for this, but today the focus is Russia.

Russia’s ultimate trump card is its status as a nuclear power — and the one with the largest arsenal. This has acted as a double-edged sword. On one hand, it is always the final card Russia can theoretically pull. On the other, under the logic of mutually assured destruction, the actual risk of nuclear war becomes extremely low — dependent on a non-rational leader bypassing restraints, or their underlings and generals choosing to follow them. Unfortunately for Russia, nuclear threats have become its primary mode of deterrence, one that is no longer taken particularly seriously.

Russia has repeatedly imposed red lines on allied nations supplying military aid to Ukraine. First it was Javelins. Then artillery systems. Then the major issue became F-16s. Each was framed as a critical escalation. Yet when these lines were crossed, there was no meaningful retaliation. Some argue Russia responded with increased bombing and drone strikes, but this is underwhelming given that Russia is already at war with Ukraine.

Now, with Bella-1, Russia reportedly deployed a submarine and other naval assets to shadow the vessel — but this raises more questions than answers. What was the actual plan? A submarine does not possess a practical means to stop a boarding operation, and any retaliation would have been immediately visible from the air. Ultimately, the now Russian-registered tanker was boarded with little response or action from Moscow.

Before And After The Invasion Of Ukraine
There is also an important contrast to be made with 2019. At that time, Russia reportedly floated the idea to the Trump administration of a geopolitical trade,  effectively swapping influence in Venezuela for U.S. concessions over Ukraine. This was a period when Russia was still far more respected, and arguably feared, on the world stage. The invasion of Ukraine had not yet occurred, sanctions were lighter, and Russia’s deterrence carried more weight.

Fast-forward five years. Maduro has been extracted. Years of Russian investment (billions poured into Venezuela militarily, economically, and diplomatically) have effectively evaporated in a matter of days. A regime Moscow spent years propping up is gone, and Russia was unable to prevent it or meaningfully respond. On the world stage, the outcome is stark.

We have seen similar episodes before. In 2015, Turkey shot down a Russian Su-24 operating in Syria, triggering a regional crisis. Turkey won the soft-power contest by framing the shoot-down as a lawful defence of its airspace and anchoring itself to NATO legitimacy. Russia’s sanctions and aggressive rhetoric made Moscow look reactive, while Ankara appeared restrained and confident. Despite Russia’s military dominance in Syria, it ultimately sought reconciliation on Turkey’s terms — signalling where the leverage lay.
Note: Turkey never publicly apologised for the incident. 

The difference between 2015 and now is that sanctions on Russia were far less severe at the time. Today, Russia’s ability to project soft power has eroded even further. With Russia bogged down in Ukraine, albeit winning a war of attrition, two things have become clear. First, Russia’s image as a global power, particularly in the West, has been severely damaged, emboldening opposing actors who might previously have hesitated. Second, being tied down in Ukraine limits Russia’s ability to deploy military assets and intelligence elsewhere, including incidents like Bella-1.

This is further compounded by sanctions, which not only constrain Russia economically but also prevent it from leveraging economic influence as a form of soft power. The result is a widening gap between Russia’s rhetoric and its ability to enforce outcomes — and that, more than any mystery cargo, is the real story here.

Sources
News/Journal sources available upon request, not shown to maintain visual integrity of page.

TWEET OF THE DAY

Honestly, can’t make this sh!t up…

TODAY IN HISTORY

(January 8, 1997): Anniversary of Grimaldi rule in Monaco

On this day in 1997, the principality of Monaco began a yearlong celebration in honour of the 700th anniversary of the rule of the Grimaldi family, who seized power in 1297 and gained firm possession of Monaco in 1419.